The Old Stone Presbyterian Church was built in 1796. It is the oldest church still in continuous use west of the Allegheny Mountains. It was erected under the direction of Col. John Stuart who also composed and carved the inscription stone above the main doorway. The church has rough limestone walls, stands two stories tall, and has two tiers of rectangular windows with shutters. The original square meetinghouse was expanded in 1830 which gave it the current rectangular shape. In 1834, an octagonal belfry with an ogee-domed roof was centered on the new hipped roof. The bell was cast in 1855 by Meneely Foundry of Troy, New York.
In 1909–1910, a brick Sunday school building with a Doric portico was built north of the church and hosted the denomination’s General Assembly in 1910. A few years after that, The Presbyterian Synod of West Virginia was formed there.
The church cemetery is the oldest in Lewisburg. There are many old stone markers that are said to have been carved east of the Alleghenies and brought in by oxcart. Henry Erskine’s marble tombstone stands six and one-half feet tall and is decorated with a carved Masonic insignia that was commissioned in 1848 by Erskine’s son-in-law.
It is thought to be West Virginia’s only remaining example of a design by Alexander Jackson Davis. Davis’s daybook contains sketches of the monument, along with records of its cost. It was fabricated and carved at the Tuckahoe Marble Quarry in Westchester County, New York.
By: Cindie Harper
The Old Stone Presbyterian Church Cemetery in Lewisburg, West Virginia has its very own “Angel of Death.” This statue marks the final resting place of an 11 year old girl named Maud Mentague (Montague) Mathews.
It should be noted that West Virginia Vital Records has Maud listed as Maud “Mentague” Mathews but her tombstone actually reads “Maud Montague Mathews.” Different local folklore versions say that Maud passed away from fluid on her lungs, influenza, or pneumonia. Being the curious researcher that I am, I checked her death record and confirmed that Maud passed away from pneumonia.
Maud was born on October 2, 1876 to Alexander R.F. and Laura G. Mathews and died on May 30, 1888. Legend tells that Maud’s grief-stricken parents had the carved angel statue made to mark her final resting place. Maud’s friends and family held a small ceremony to commemorate the placing of the angel statue at the site of her grave. During this ceremony, folklore states that two of Maud’s best friends, a set of cousins who were said to be approximately 14 years old, each placed a kiss on a cheek of the angel in memory of their lost friend. Shortly after the ceremony, one of the girls fell ill herself. The legend states that she contracted the influenza virus and died of fluid on the lungs, similar to the way Maud had died. A short time later, the second girl broke her ribs in a carriage accident. Her lungs were punctured, causing them to fill with blood which resulted in her death. The three young girls dying from fluid on their lungs, less than a year apart, caused quite a buzz in this small town. Shortly after that, the locals began referring to the angel statue as the “Angel of Death.” Legend states that anyone brave enough or foolish enough to kiss the statue will die within a year.
Although I was unable to find any details, there are rumors that the angel is able to foretell the deaths of some of the people who come to visit the ominous “Angel of Death.” So far, I have not been able to verify the deaths of the other two girls mentioned in this legend. I was able to find a few death records that leave room for the possibility of some truth to it though.
If you plan on visiting the “Angel of Death,” it is located in Section C-2 of the Old Stone Presbyterian Church Cemetery in Lewisburg, West Virginia. When I visited this cemetery earlier this month, I was immediately drawn to this statue and even remarked on how creepy and ominous it appeared to be. Perhaps the fact that the statue had a children’s play area and a picnic table nearby, made the “Angel of Death” a bit more creeptastic to me. Since I am not one to accept others’ beliefs as my own, my curious nature got the best of me and I gave that Angel of Death a kiss on each cheek!! All in the name of research of course.
By: Cindie Harper
The Walters House is a national register property. It is located at 221 Willey Street. It was designed aroubd 1900 by Elmer Jacobs. This home has a hipped roof tower with curved glass in the tower, stained glass windows on the stairways, and brick and stone trim.
The home has served as a rooming house and home to the University Christian Council. It is now home to legal offices. In the late 1960s, when the building housed the Christian Council, they gave it the name Bennett House in honor of Vietnam War conscientious objector Thomas W. Bennett.
Serving as a medic in the war, Bennett lost his life while attempting to save that of another. Congress awarded him the Congressional Medal of Honor posthumously for his deeds.
276 Walnut Street in Morgantown, West Virginia. This building was originally the Shisler home. It was constructed by Elmer Jacobs. This home was built in 1902 and is among the last homes constructed in the downtown area. It has Palladian windows and dormers with pediments and reflects a Colonial Revival style. It is currently housing Morgantown Beauty College. It is located next door to the Appalachian Gallery which was originally known as the Price home.
The historic Price House, also known as the Sandcastle Building, is currently housing the Appalachian Gallery.
It is located at 270 Walnut Street, Morgantown West Virginia, next to Morgantown Beauty College.
This house is 114 years old. There have been extensive renovations completed on this building. Restoration of the original stained-glass windows, decorative plasterwork, pocket doors, and hardwood floors have been completed.
This stone residence is almost exactly like the Garlow home on Spruce Street which is currently home to the Aull Center and Holocaust Museum.
This building has served as a fraternity house, restaurant, and an office building. Like the Aull Center (Garlow residence), it was designed by Elmer Jacobs. It is the Queen Anne Revival style and has some of the finest stained-glass windows in the area.